So. There is an opera of Hamlet.
This is a thing that exists.
Honestly, I enjoyed it; it is BEAUTIFUL. Seriously, I loved the music, the set, the costumes, the concept behind staging it all with a an iron curtain/fascist context.
But. Uh.
Ok. So, there are apparently a couple different versions of the opera—the original has Hamlet and Ophelia living at the end of the play. You heard that right. The original composer thought that Hamlet was too bloody of a play, so he…wrote…a fixit fanfic, and set it to beautiful music. And the French loved it.
When they took it to England, they realized that the English…might not appreciate the happy ending. Y’know. They had a hunch. Hamlet is just considered one of the greatest English plays ever written, and if you called it a national treasure you wouldn’t be laughed out of the room.
So, he grudgingly put in the end where everybody dies. He just…added it. So everybody dies. But not in the context of the story, and certainly not as a tragic family all getting their comeuppances and having their tragic flaws exposed for all the world to see, and resulting in their demise—they just…die.
So, it’s a fixit fanfic, fixed again.
It also had some interesting stuff in it, traditional-Hamlet-wise.
A lot of parts were necessarily…uh…not there. Like. Polonius has like one line in the entire show. And he’s super competent, and totally in on Claudius’s plot, and doesn’t make an ass out of himself at all. And Horatio…
Ok. So in this production, its pretty clear that Hamlet is completely off his rocker, and it’s all set off by Horatio and Banquo being drunk and telling Hamlet they saw his father’s ghost. Then passing out and forgetting about it.
They don’t really do much else, Hamlet and Horatio don’t bother talking, they aren’t really buddies. Like I said. Fanfiction.
The oddest addition to the opera vs the play has got to be the wine is awesome, lets all drink our troubles away song. Where Hamlet gets totally plastered and the players have just done their thing, and Claudius is freaking out, and suddenly, in front of the whole court, Hamlet starts shrieking (singing beautifully!) that there is the proof of Claudius and Gertrude’s guilt, and the whole court starts staring at Hamlet, and then they all start singing about how drunk poor, mad, Hamlet is.
That, ah, didn’t happen in the play. Just in the opera.
See, I’m going to have trouble talking about this as an opera and not as Hamlet. Because I love Hamlet. And this opera was great—really! It was great! But I couldn’t separate it from Hamlet. And I just felt like I was watching the highest budget fanfiction I’ve ever seen.
Now, I do love fanfiction. So go. See it. Watch Hamlet lose his mind, and Ophelia finally getting her death monologue, and singing one of the most amazing arias I’ve heard on the stage (not as awesome as Lucia or Night Queen’s, but in that category. Seriously, it was good). Watch Ophelia’s madness be more than literary madness—she sort of went with a borderline/depressive/manic angle, complete with self-harm behaviors from the beginning.
So! Onto my wife’s sketches!
This last weekend, we saw the newest world premiere of the MN Opera’s New Works Initiative—you’ll remember the last ones we saw was SilentNight, and The Giver.
I’ve been looking forward to this one, since frankly, the new operas have been among my favorites. Doubt, as in the play and movie of the same name, written by the same person, did not disappoint.
For those who haven’t been keeping up with such things, Doubt was first an award winning play (Pulitzer), then it was a star studded (notably, Meryl Streep), award winning movie (SAG Award for Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role, BFCA Critics’ Choice Award for Best Actress, National Board of Review Award for Best Acting by an Ensemble).
So, uh. It’s got good bones.
I haven’t seen the movie or the play. I intend to fix that ASAP.
Here’s the basic rundown of the plot. I’ll talk about the music in a moment.
The story is set in 1964. The civil rights movement is in full swing, Kennedy’s assassination is still making waves, the US is being torn apart by the Vietnam War, and Vatican II was starting to make itself known and shaking up the Catholic Church and upsetting people.
Especially people like our Leading Lady, Sister Aloysius, principal of a Catholic boarding school. She’s a staunch conservative; she’s older and has been in the biz of being a teacher/principal in catholic school since her husband died many years ago. The students are terrified into respect at her presence, and she rules her school with the kind of iron fist that gives nuns the formidable reputation in fiction and real life they still enjoy.
Sister Aloysius in her office, terrorizing Father Flynn
Its unfortunate for her, then, that the new Priest of the church connected to the school is one of the liberal upstarts that have embraced Vatican II. He’s personable, he drinks with the bishop, he does his Mass in English, he isn’t opposed to secular Christmas songs, and he feels like he should be one of the families to all his parishioners. Father Flynn, he of the pretty baritone, and symbol of all that is a-changing.
Father Flynn and his altar boys/choir. Cool use of color here.
He’s also…a bit touchy-feely with the boys of the school. Particularly, the first black boy to be allowed into the school, Donald Miller.
And Sister Aloysius, looking for a reason, any reason, to see the worst in Father Flynn/get rid of the man, hears about a bit of impropriety (remember, she’s so conservative she thinks fire might go out of style any day now), and says, “So. It’s finally happened here.”
She’s been around enough to have seen Priests take advantage of students before. She’s also been around long enough to know just how much the church hierarchy cares about such things. If she follows her chain of command, she’ll just be telling Father Flynn’s current drinking buddy and pal the Monsignor. And he’ll jus dismiss her concerns. She knows this.
She ropes a younger nun, Sister James, one without her worldly experience, one without her suspicious nature, into being a third party to the drama she’s about to unfold. Sister Aloysius tells Sister James, “Innocence can only be wisdom in a world without evil.”
And boy does she think she’s found evil.
Sister Aloysius contemplating the nature of evil
Father Flynn, for his part, is either a world-class liar or he’s innocent. Which is, of course the whole point. He’s certainly doing some things that could, if you were inclined to think in that direction, be incredibly damning. But he’s got reasonable explanations for each of them. He spends a lot of time with Donald Miller because he is worried that the boy will be bullied by the other students. He had a closed door meeting with Donald, who seemed to be drunk afterward—but the janitor was the one to bring him to the Priest after catching Donald drinking the altar wine. Father Flynn wanted to keep the incident quiet because if anybody knew about it, Donald would get in trouble—and his father is abusive. He tried to hide a shirt of Donald’s—again, to keep the stealing altar wine thing a secret.
I’m just saying, Sister Aloysius has a point. Father Flynn is kind of not doing a good job of appearing like a dude on the up and up.
She confronts him. He reacts…well, if you were inclined to think in a different direction, he reacts like an innocent priestly dude told he’s been molesting little boys by a nun that hates everything he does. Which is to say, not well.
Sister James believes him. Sister Aloysius sees his little temper tantrum as defensiveness, and doubles down on her certainty that he is guilty. And decides that if Father Flynn won’t resign or admit to guilt to the higher ups, and they won’t do anything about him, she’ll have to run him out of the priesthood, and until then, Donald should probably leave the school.
She calls Donald’s mother.
Its important to note, here, that Sister Aloysius sees the world in complete black and white with no shades of grey.
Donald’s mother, however, knows that all that is waiting at home for her son is a messy death at the hands of his father. See, she and her husband suspect that Donald is gay. And her response is maybe not what the good sister expects—that it’s only till June, that even if it is true, at least Father Flynn is an otherwise good man and wouldn’t hurt him. That it is only ‘till June. And no matter what Father Flynn is doing, even if its hurting her son, he’s not going to kill him. So, no. She won’t pull her son out of the school. If the nun must get rid of somebody, it has to be the priest, and her son must be left out of it.
Mrs. Miller, in the middle of her amazing showstopping number. She has one song, but she stole the show. GO TEAM ALTO!
Sister Aloysius’s certainty is not swerved, but she will at least throw her energies behind getting rid of Father Flynn. And to that end, she confronts him again, telling him to resign, telling him that she’s finally got real proof, that she called his last posting, and talked to the nuns there and got some real, but vague dirt on him. She implies that they said he molested little boys there too, but—and this is important, she never explicitly says that.
But he does resign. He calls up the chain of command and requests a transfer. He leaves.
Gossip is like feathers thrown off a balcony–the effects are impossible to take back.
Sister Aloysius is triumphant, if feeling a bit guilty—she sorta lied about calling the last place he had been. She made it up, bore false witness—y’know, mortal sin and all that. But it was for the greater good, right? Well…
Father Flynn was transferred. To the position of principal of an all boys boarding school.
So. Uh. Yay?
Don’t worry, Sister Aloysius. If you were right, he’s just in charge of a school full of his prey. But you could be wrong! …and commited a mortal sin against an innocent man and given him a reputation as a child molester. Hm. Nobody wins here, do they?
Well, if he’s innocent, no harm no foul. But he is hiding something; he tells us so in the first song. And he did capitulate to Sister Aloysius’s blackmail. So. Doubt.
Yeah, you saw what I did there.
The did he/didn’t he debate is kinda old hat by now—and I suspect changes for everyone on the staging, what the actors and director think about it, and I suspect, changes between performances and the little nuances that change between shows. A touch of a shoulder there, the lack of physical contact here, significant looks and a sudden decision to be louder or softer for this stanza or that one.
In the performance I saw, most folks thought he did it. Some thought he did something else, and was driven out by the threat to his reputation, and not an actual known stain.
It’s very good. Enough about the plot though—how is it as an opera?
It’s fabulous. Christine Brewer’s Sister Aloysius is powerful, believable, and her voice soars and fills the space. She’s an experienced operatic soprano, and it shows. She’s damn near perfect for the part, and it was a joy to hear her. Father Flynn’s baritone was smooth and clean and rode the line between too smooth to be real and innocent being hounded because of his new-fangled approach to religion. And Denyce Graves, as Mrs. Miller, knocked her part out of the park.
There were also kids—many of whom I think I recognized from The Giver, and they were awesome, middle school kids being kids and being awful to each other, and trying to kiss each other and playing around with being preteens. Well cast, and I particularly enjoyed the “booger, booger, booger” chorus, after one of them was chided for picking his nose. Opera is serious business folks.
All in all, if you can, GO SEE THIS. It’s wonderful, it’s moving, and the talent on display is top notch. More drawings by Lee to follow:
Innocence is only wisdom in a world without evil. Sister James having a crisis of innocence.We were fortunate enough to once again be invited to view the MN Opera Companies Comic Artists Night at the Opera this past week. This time, the show was Anna Bolena. Full disclosure- I have a special affinity for opera of this kind, called “Bell Canto” style, that really focuses on all those crazy vocal gymnastics opera singers are capable of, and on the singing itself.
Anna Bolena is about King Henry the 8ths 2nd wife, Anna, and the process by which she was usurped and executed. It had about as much basis in historical events as your average movie blockbuster, but that’s ok, because it made for good theatre. This opera is the 1st of 3 operas by this composer about the lives of the Tudors. For reasons nobody can seem to remember, the company chose to produce them in reverse order. So, last year we saw the opera about Queen Elizabeth Vs Mary, and this year we saw an opera about Elizabeths mother. Little bitty Elizabeth even showed up a couple of times, and in the final scene was in a childrens version of the dress she wore in the final scene of Mary Stuart.
So, the basic plot is this, Anna is anxiously contemplating the fact that she hasn’t been able to provide Henry with a male heir yet, meanwhile Henry is snaking around with Annas best buddy, anddeclarng intentions to marry her. In the meantime, an old flame of Annas is allowed back from exile at Henrys say-so. Annas brother talks her into seeing him, because he seems to be just about loosing his mind about her. He sneaks into her rooms to see her, and tries to woo her. She admits that she hates being Henrys wife, feels bad about having ousted Henrys first wife, and pretty much admits she’s still in love with him. At this point, a minstrel page-boy who has a crush on Anna rushes out from where he was hiding in her rooms waiting for her, flips out, and sends other people coming to see what the ruckus is about. He also drops a locket that he stole out of Annas room, that has her picture in it. Henry storms onto the scene, declares that she has been unfaithful to him, and that that’s treason, so she should be put to death. The page boy tries to speak up for her, saying that she didn’t actually do anything (although the choreography in at least this productions seems to set up that the only reason she didn’t was that she hadn’t had the time) and so the kind has him arrested to. The kid is tortured until he admits Anna was unfaithful. Anna is locked up in the tower to await a trial that pretty much everyone admits is a complete farce of a formality. Her buddy whose been messing around with Henry shows up to try to convince her to admit she was cheating so that maybe Henry will only exile her. She says she can’t shame the throne or herself like that. They have an oddly touching moment of friendship. Annas brother and would-be-beua are also locked up and slated to be executed. Henry agrees to pardon Annas brother, but he decides to be killed anyways out of solidarity. Then there’s a brief trial, Anna is unsurprisingly convicted. Her buddy tries to convince the king to spare her, but he’s having none of it. Anna is executed. Henry marries her freind. Spoilers, Spoilers, I know, but looking up that Ann Bolin dies is a simple wikipedia search.
Ok, the plot is fairly daytime-TV, but the acting was excellent and the music and visuals were sublime. They reused some of the set pieces we saw in their production of Mary Stuart, for one thing, which I thought was a nice and thought provoking piece of continuity. I honestly do suggest giving it a look if you live in MN. Tickets start at $20, which is not bad at all.
On to the pictures! As always, click the thumbnail to enlarge. These were all drawn on my iPad during the show itself.
